Ashley was murdered fifteen years ago. Her killer was caught. Or so everyone believes. When Crystal's body is discovered under eerily familiar circumstances, the members of the True Crime Club start to notice what local law enforcement refuses to admit - the two cases are connected. The sheriff calls it coincidence. The club calls it murder. What starts as an amateur investigation quickly spirals into something far more dangerous. As the teens dig deeper into old case files, corrupted evidence, and buried secrets, they uncover a web of lies that implicates people in the highest places of their small town. The man convicted of Ashley's murder may have been the wrong man all along - and the real killer may have been hiding in plain sight for fifteen years. Now, with every answer they uncover, the True Crime Club moves closer to a truth that someone is willing to kill to protect. And once they get too close... they may become the next victims. 15 years. Two murders. One truth.